Four layers: can a crawler read the site, does it load inside Google’s published thresholds, can a visitor use it, and does a request reach a person. Reports cover the first two well, the third partly, the fourth not at all.
What does a website audit actually check?
Four questions, asked in order. The last one is the only one with revenue attached, and the only one no scanner can answer.
robots.txt, canonical tags, HTTPS, titles and headings. A crawler either reaches your pages or it does not.
The three Core Web Vitals, measured against Google’s published thresholds on real Chrome traffic, not a lab guess.
Contrast, labels, alt text. The failures that stop a person who is already on the page and ready to ask.
What happens in the minutes after a form submit or a call. Not scannable, and the only layer with revenue attached.



Present on 98.5% of pages. Close to universal (HTTP Archive, 2025).
On 91.5% of mobile pages. A baseline, not a differentiator; a report that leads with it is padding.
A valid 200 on 84.9% of sites. That proves the file exists, not that its directives are right.
An h1 present on 70% of mobile pages and non-empty on 66%. Canonical tags on 67%, meta descriptions on 67.2%.
What does "slow" mean in an audit report?
Three numbers published by Google, measured on real visits at the 75th percentile, split by mobile and desktop. "Slow" with no metric attached is not a finding.
Thresholds from Google’s Web Vitals documentation (web.dev, updated October 2024). A page passes if it meets all three at that percentile.
View data
| Step | Value |
|---|---|
| Largest Contentful Paint | 2.5 s (the main content has loaded) |
| Interaction to Next Paint | 200 ms (the page responds to a tap) |
| Cumulative Layout Shift | 0.1 (nothing jumps while you read) |
| percentile of real page loads | 75th (all three, mobile and desktop separately) |
Mobile sites with good Core Web Vitals
44%48%
HTTP Archive, 2024 to 2025.
Desktop sites with good Core Web Vitals
55%56%
Same dataset, same two years.
View data
| Metric | Day zero → target |
|---|---|
| Mobile sites with good Core Web Vitals | 44% → 48% |
| Desktop sites with good Core Web Vitals | 55% → 56% |



HTTP Archive, Web Almanac 2025 (16,213,084 sites from the Chrome UX Report)
View data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Desktop, all pages | 56% |
| Mobile, secondary pages | 56% |
| Mobile, all pages | 48% |
| Mobile, home pages | 45% |
Does an audit check whether a real person can use the page?
The good ones do, and it is where the failure rate is highest. WebAIM found detected WCAG 2 failures on 95.9% of the top 1,000,000 home pages, up from 94.8% a year earlier.
On 83.9% of home pages (WebAIM Million, February 2026).
On 53.1%.
On 51%.
On 46.3%.
On 30.6%.
On 13.5%. These six types made up 96% of everything detected, and the same six have topped the list for seven years.



One input in three on it is unlabeled, so a screen reader, an autofill routine and a thumb on a phone all get less than your designer assumed.
Errors per home page rose 10.1% in a year, and page complexity rose 14.3% to 1,437 elements.
WebAIM used the WAVE engine on the rendered DOM, and says automated tools cannot catch every failure. True full conformance was certainly below 4.1%.
Which check decides whether the phone rings?
The one no scanner performs: what happens in the minutes after someone contacts you. You test it by hand, on your own site, with your own phone.
Passes every automated check.
Passes every automated check.
Passes, and says nothing about whether a person replied.
- 01Submit your own formFrom a phone, on cellular data, not the office wifi. Use a real email you can check.
- 02Start a timerNote when the first reply arrives, and whether it came from a person or from nothing at all.
- 03Call the number on the pageAfter hours, on a weekend. Count the rings, then listen to whatever answers.
- 04Write down both numbersMinutes to first reply, and whether the call reached a human. That pair is your real audit score.
Minutes to first reply is its own subject: how fast you have to answer a new lead.
Does a website audit still matter if AI answers the question first?
Yes, for a different reason: fewer searches send a visit at all, so each one that arrives is worth more, and the page now also supplies the text that answering engines quote.



They appeared on more than 20% of searches and cut click-through by nearly 60% when present (SparkToro, 2026).
The panel covers mobile searches in a browser, not the Google search app, where the authors expect zero-click behavior to be more aggressive still.
Google’s own AI guidance says it is not required for generative AI search and there is no special markup to add. JSON-LD sat on 43% of home pages in 2025, and which types earn a rich result changes without notice, as when Google retired FAQ rich results.
Readable HTML, real headings, plain answers near the top, facts in text rather than inside an image. An audit checks exactly that.
How do you read an audit report without buying the wrong fix?
Run every finding through three questions, in order. Google itself says there is no single page experience signal and that chasing a perfect score may not be the best use of your time.
- 01Which number in my business changes if this is fixed?Calls answered, forms delivered, booked jobs. If the honest answer is "none, but the score goes up," it is housekeeping.
- 02Is this measured on real visits or on a lab test?Core Web Vitals come from real Chrome traffic at the 75th percentile. A one-off synthetic score on an office connection is a hint, not a measurement.
- 03Is it on the path between a stranger and a booked job?Find the page, read the page, submit the form, get a reply. Defects on that path outrank everything else on the report.
- 01Unblock indexing
- 02Fix the contact path
- 03Label the form
- 04Speed up the pages that get traffic
The machine-readable half is what our site check runs: indexability, speed, the contact elements it can see, and your Google listing. The phone test is still yours to run, and it is the half that decides whether the rest mattered.
Questions owners ask
What does a website audit include?
Indexability (robots.txt, canonical, HTTPS), speed (Core Web Vitals against Google’s 2.5 seconds, 200 milliseconds and 0.1 thresholds), usability (contrast, labels, alt text), and the contact path: what happens after a form submit. Reports cover the first two well, the last not at all.
Do Core Web Vitals affect Google rankings?
Yes, and less than audit reports imply. Google’s own documentation says there is no single page experience signal, good Core Web Vitals do not put pages at the top of Search, and chasing a perfect score may not be the best use of your time.
What is the most common problem a website audit finds?
Low contrast text, on 83.9% of the top 1,000,000 home pages (WebAIM, February 2026), ahead of missing alt text at 53.1% and missing form labels at 51%. Six issue types made up 96% of all errors, the same six for seven years.
Is a free website audit worth anything?
It is worth what it measures: the machine-readable half. A scan reads robots.txt, pulls Core Web Vitals from real Chrome traffic and flags unlabeled inputs. It cannot tell whether anyone answered the call from the page. Test that by submitting your own form.
Sources
- Google, web.dev: Web Vitals (Core Web Vitals thresholds; published May 4, 2020, last updated Oct 31, 2024) (2024)
- Google Search Central: Understanding page experience in Google Search results (2026)
- HTTP Archive, Web Almanac 2025, Performance chapter (16,213,084 websites sourced from the Chrome UX Report, July 2025 crawl) (2025)
- HTTP Archive, Web Almanac 2025, SEO chapter (same dataset) (2025)
- WebAIM, The WebAIM Million: accessibility evaluation of the top 1,000,000 home pages (February 2026) (2026)
- Google Search Central: Get your content in AI features (structured data guidance) (2026)
- SparkToro with Similarweb, In 2026, Less than One Third of Google Searches Still Send a Click (Similarweb desktop and mobile web panel, US, January to April 2026) (2026)
The first meeting starts with findings, not promises.The free Business Health Report reads your business and shows you what it found, in days.
Get Your Free Business Health Report



